WeVote
Log In

Bill

WeVote Research Nonpartisan
Bill Summary · HB 2667

Legislative bill overview

HB 2667, the "Eliminate Criminal Profiteering Act," aims to restrict or prevent individuals convicted of crimes from profiting through book deals, movie rights, speaking engagements, or other commercial ventures related to their notoriety. This type of legislation is often called a "Son of Sam" law, named after similar statutes designed to redirect such proceeds to crime victims or state crime victim funds.

Why is this important

These laws address public concerns about criminals benefiting financially from the attention their crimes generate while victims may receive little compensation. However, they raise significant First Amendment questions about whether restricting commercial speech based on criminal history violates free speech rights, a tension courts have grappled with for decades.

Potential points of contention

  • First Amendment concerns: Courts have struck down overly broad versions of these laws as unconstitutional restrictions on speech and press freedom; the specific language matters greatly
  • Scope and definitions: Determining what constitutes "profiteering" (autobiography vs. fiction? commentary vs. narrative?) and which crimes apply creates enforcement challenges
  • Victim compensation mechanisms: Questions about how seized proceeds are distributed, whether they actually reach victims, and administrative costs of collection and distribution
  • Due process issues: Concerns about how long restrictions apply and whether they constitute additional punishment beyond sentencing

Compiled from official sources — confirm details with the bill’s official record.

Sign in to ask a question.