WeVote
Log In

Bill

RA

Bill

A 3735

Establishes crime of fertility fraud.

2024-2025 Regular Session Introduced by Reginald Atkins and 4 co-sponsors

New Jersey bill criminalizes deception about fertility status or contraceptive use to obtain non-consensual reproduction or sexual activity, addressing reproductive autonomy but raising enforcement and definitional challenges.

Reported and Referred to Assembly Appropriations Committee
#crimproced #crimes
0
WeVote Research Nonpartisan
Bill Summary · A 3735

Legislative bill overview

Bill A 3735 creates a new criminal offense in New Jersey for "fertility fraud," which would penalize individuals who misrepresent their fertility status, contraceptive use, or ability to have children in order to deceive a partner into sexual activity or reproduction. The bill aims to provide legal recourse for individuals who claim to have been deceived about reproductive intentions or contraceptive status. The specific penalties and enforcement mechanisms are determined by the bill's statutory language.

Why is this important

Reproductive deception—whether involving contraception, fertility status, or intentions regarding parenthood—can have profound personal, financial, and health consequences for victims, potentially leading to unwanted pregnancies, STI transmission, or emotional trauma. Establishing it as a distinct crime would signal legal recognition of reproductive autonomy as a protected interest. However, the definition and enforcement of such crimes raise significant practical and constitutional questions about consent, proof, and bodily autonomy.

Potential points of contention

  • Definitional clarity: "Fertility fraud" requires clear legal definition of what constitutes actionable deception versus disputed claims about reproductive intent, which are often difficult to prove and involve subjective understandings between partners
  • Burden of proof and prosecution: Establishing criminal intent and proving what was said or understood in private intimate relationships presents significant evidentiary challenges and could incentivize false accusations
  • Gender and application concerns: Critics worry such laws may be applied asymmetrically or weaponized in custody disputes, while supporters argue it addresses real harms disproportionately affecting women deceived about contraceptive use

Compiled from official sources — confirm details with the bill’s official record.

Sign in to ask a question.