WeVote
Log In

Bill

Bill

A 3746

Clarifies that encouraging another person to cause bodily injury, by filming, photographing, or otherwise recording injury-causing act, is form of crime of endangering injured victim.

2024-2025 Regular Session Introduced by Carol Murphy

New Jersey bill criminalizes filming/recording someone causing bodily injury with intent to encourage the violent act, treating documentation as active participation in endangering the victim.

Introduced in the Assembly, Referred to Assembly Judiciary Committee
#crimproced #crimes
0
WeVote Research Nonpartisan
Bill Summary · A 3746

Legislative bill overview

Bill A 3746 clarifies that recording or filming someone committing bodily injury against another person—with the intent to encourage that harmful act—constitutes a crime of endangering the injured victim. The bill essentially expands liability to include those who document and encourage violence through recording, not just those who physically commit it.

Why is this important

This addresses a real phenomenon where bystanders film violence to encourage or incite it rather than seek help. The bill attempts to close a legal loophole where someone could film an assault while actively encouraging it without facing direct criminal culpability for the injury itself. It reflects evolving concerns about social media encouragement of violence and mob participation in harmful acts.

Potential points of contention

  • First Amendment concerns: Critics may argue that recording itself is protected speech, and the bill could criminalize documentation of crimes or police misconduct; the distinction between "encouraging" versus simply "recording" may be legally ambiguous
  • Proof of intent: Determining whether someone recording "encouraged" the injury versus merely documenting it could be difficult and subjective, potentially leading to inconsistent prosecution
  • Scope ambiguity: The bill doesn't clearly define what constitutes "encouraging" through recording—does it require verbal statements, physical gestures, or is the act of filming and sharing itself sufficient evidence of encouragement?

Compiled from official sources — confirm details with the bill’s official record.

Sign in to ask a question.