Bill
H 3044
Courts may order surgical castration for certain adult sex offenders (Tier II/III with victims 13 or younger) when required to register, if a medical expert approves.
Note on source materials: The file provided contains mixed/duplicative materials from more than one jurisdiction and bill text. The operative substantive text below reflects the explicit statutory language repeatedly included in the packet: an addition of Section 23‑3‑435 to the South Carolina Code (authorizing court‑ordered surgical castration in specified sex‑offense cases). There are also unrelated Massachusetts docket pages (a separate bill on 401(k) tax treatment) included in the packet; those are not the subject of the castration provisions summarized here. Please verify the correct jurisdiction and final bill text with the legislative clerk if needed.
Purpose and intent
- To authorize courts to order surgical castration, in addition to other penalties, for certain adult offenders convicted of Tier II or Tier III sex offenses who must register on the Sex Offender Registry when the victim was age 13 or younger.
Key provisions
- Adds Section 23‑3‑435 to the South Carolina Code.
- Scope (Subsection A): Applies to offenders who were 18 or older at time of the offense, convicted of a Tier II or Tier III offense under Section 23‑3‑430, where the victim was 13 years old or younger, and the offender is required to register on the Sex Offender Registry. The court “may” (discretionary) sentence surgical castration in addition to other punishments.
- Procedure and timing (Subsection B): A court order for surgical castration is contingent on a court‑appointed medical expert determining the offender is an appropriate candidate; that determination must be made within 60 days of sentencing. If the offender is incarcerated, the procedure must be performed no later than one week before release.
- Penalty for noncompliance (Subsection C): If an offender fails to appear for the procedure or refuses it, the offender is to be charged under this section; upon conviction the offender faces imprisonment up to 5 years, with no suspension, probation, or parole allowed.
- Medical exception (Subsection D): The statute does not require surgical castration when it is not medically appropriate.
- Effective date and savings clause: Act takes effect upon the Governor’s approval; a savings clause preserves pending actions and liabilities under repealed/amended laws.
Who would be affected
- Adult offenders (18+) convicted of qualifying Tier II/III sex offenses with victims aged 13 or younger and subject to sex‑offender registration.
- South Carolina Department of Corrections (responsible for administering the procedure by a licensed physician under the bill’s language).
- Courts, medical experts appointed by courts, correctional medical services, and prosecutors (for enforcement of the noncompliance provision).
Procedural/timeline notes (as provided)
- Prefiled: 12/05/2024; filed versions dated 12/05/2024 and 02/04/2025 in the provided packet.
- Some items show introductions and referrals to a Judiciary committee and hearings tentatively scheduled for 11/18/2025 (multiple entries). Sponsors added in early 2025 per the action log.
Potential legal and implementation considerations (observations, not legal conclusions)
- The measure raises substantial legal, constitutional (e.g., Eighth Amendment cruel‑and‑unusual punishment), medical ethics, consent, and human‑rights issues that could prompt litigation.
- Practical implementation would require DOC medical capacity, procedures for court‑appointed medical evaluations, and budgeting for surgical/medical care and oversight.
For verification: confirm the bill number, sponsoring jurisdiction, and final enacted text before citing or acting on this summary.
Compiled from official sources — confirm details with the bill’s official record.
Sign in to ask a question.
