WeVote
Log In

Bill

WeVote Research Nonpartisan
Bill Summary · HB 1267

Legislative bill overview

HB 1267 would establish a mechanism allowing the Texas Legislature to recall a United States Senator through a legislative vote. This would fundamentally alter the relationship between state legislatures and federal representation, as current law only permits Senate vacancies to be filled through gubernatorial appointment or special election. The bill represents an attempt to restore a power that states exercised before the 17th Amendment (1913) changed Senate selection from legislative appointment to direct popular election.

Why is this important

This proposal directly challenges the constitutional framework of Senate representation and democratic accountability. If enacted, it would shift significant political power from Texas voters to the state legislature, potentially allowing legislators to remove a Senator based on policy disagreements rather than constituent will. This raises fundamental questions about representative democracy and whether elected officials should answer primarily to voters or to state legislators.

Potential points of contention

  • Constitutional validity: The 17th Amendment explicitly established direct election of Senators; courts would likely find state-imposed recall mechanisms unconstitutional as they conflict with federal constitutional design
  • Democratic representation: Voters elected the Senator directly; allowing legislative removal circumvents the popular mandate and concentrates power in the legislature
  • Partisan weaponization: The mechanism could enable a legislative majority to remove a Senator from the opposing party, reducing political stability and encouraging tit-for-tat recalls across states
  • Precedent concerns: Success in Texas could inspire similar bills nationwide, fundamentally destabilizing the Senate if multiple states adopt conflicting recall standards

Compiled from official sources — confirm details with the bill’s official record.

Sign in to ask a question.