WeVote
Log In

Bill

Bill

LD 174

An Act To Restore Religious Exemptions To Immunization Requirements

132nd Legislature (2025-2026) Introduced by Mark Babin and 9 co-sponsors

Bill would have allowed Maine families to refuse required school vaccines based on religious beliefs, reversing 2019 policy limiting exemptions to medical reasons. Bill failed 17-14 in Senate.

Placed in Legislative Files (DEAD) Roll Call Number 207 Yeas 17 - Nays 14 - Excused 3 - Absent 1
#policyexemptions #religiousexemption #schoolpolicies
0
WeVote Research Nonpartisan
Bill Summary · LD 174

Legislative bill overview

LD 174 would have restored religious exemptions to Maine's immunization requirements for school attendance and childcare. Maine eliminated religious and philosophical exemptions in 2019, keeping only medical exemptions. This bill sought to reinstate the ability for families to opt out of vaccines based on sincere religious beliefs.

Why is this important

Vaccine exemption policies directly affect disease control in schools and communities. Maine's removal of non-medical exemptions was designed to maintain herd immunity thresholds and prevent outbreaks of preventable diseases. Restoring religious exemptions could lower vaccination rates in some communities, potentially creating pockets of vulnerability to disease transmission.

Potential points of contention

  • Public health vs. religious freedom: Balances individual liberty and religious conscience against community disease prevention and protection of vulnerable populations (infants, immunocompromised individuals)
  • Exemption scope and verification: Questions about what constitutes a "sincere" religious belief, how exemptions would be verified, and whether this could be exploited for non-religious reasons
  • Precedent and timing: Maine eliminated these exemptions specifically due to measles outbreaks; restoring them contradicts that public health decision and occurs amid ongoing vaccine hesitancy debates

Compiled from official sources — confirm details with the bill’s official record.

Sign in to ask a question.